Nothing special (2009-03-03)
I purchased the white and charcoal grey pencil after reading glowing reviews. I found it to be nothing special. Sometimes the product would crumble a bit when I tried to put it on. It wasn't nearly as soft and easy to apply as I had hoped. If there's a color you couldn't find elsewhere it would probably be worth it, otherwise go to the drugstore and you could probably find a better performer for less.

Pretty good pencil (2008-10-10)
I have this eye pencil in Lagoon (I believe). I've only used it a couple of times because I don't wear eyeliner very often, but it goes on smooth,stays on pretty well and the color is a nice aqua blue. I thought the color would be a little more vibrant. But overall, it's a good deal for the quality of the product and I would buy it again.

Just OK (2008-04-21)
I know these are cheap little pencils actually perfect for your purse but they don't seem to stay on for me. I will probably stick to what I have been using in the past.

thanks,
TR

true color, hard to apply (2007-11-18)
The colors are very nice and true to what was shown on-line. The pencil is a bit too hard for a smooth application and it smears when my eyes tear. I tried using a powder over the liner to "set it" but it still tends to run. I wouldn't buy it again.

Great staple to always have on had (2007-08-21)
I really love this liner for long-lasting, smooth vibrant colors.I love the black and gunmetal style gray, its heavy enough to be noticed when I want the 'smokey' look. And the price is great..and Sephora ships lightening fast.